Your friend says it is too expensive: who to actually believe
People who will never buy make the least useful pricing panel. How to weigh opinions against what your existing buyers have already done with their money.
It happened over dinner. You mentioned the new price, and someone who loves you pulled a face and said, kindly, that they would never pay that. You laughed it off, and then you spent the drive home doing sums, and by Sunday you had drafted a lower price on your phone. One person who has never bought anything of yours has now had more influence on your pricing than all of your actual buyers combined.
Why the wrong opinion lands so hard
Because it comes from someone who matters to you, delivered in a setting where you cannot check anything. Your buyers give their verdict silently, weeks apart, by paying. Your friend gives theirs in real time, across a table, with a facial expression. The channel is far more vivid, so it wins, even though the content is worthless.
It also lands because it agrees with something you already suspect. Almost every creator carries a private conviction that the price is a bit cheeky. A stranger's shrug slides straight into that groove. If your friend had said the price was too low you would have dismissed it as loyalty within a second.
The genuinely hard part is that non-buyers are not always wrong. Sometimes the price really is out of step with what the page promises. But they are wrong in a specific way: they are pricing the product for themselves, a person outside the market, with no need for the outcome, no budget line for it, and no idea what the alternatives cost. Someone who needs the result and has been searching for it for a month is a different economy.
The people most confident that the price is too high are rarely the people holding the card.
The opinion panel versus the evidence you already own
You do not have to run a survey. Every purchase, membership and free download already builds your customer list for you, with lifetime value per person attached, and you can export the lot to CSV on any plan, including the free one.
| Asking around | Reading your own list |
|---|---|
| A friend at dinner who is not in your market | Nine people who bought twice |
| Their reaction to the number in the abstract | What people paid when the outcome was on the table |
| "I would never pay that" | Lifetime value per person, over months |
| No information about the alternatives they considered | Buyers who upgraded from a small product to a large one |
| Feedback loudest from those furthest from buying | Feedback from people with a receipt |
| A number chosen to survive dinner conversation | A number chosen to survive your accounts |
How to check the evidence in twenty minutes
Do this before you change anything. It is mostly reading, and it usually ends the argument with yourself. Your per-product analytics sit alongside the customer list, so both readings fit in one sitting.
- 1Open Customers in your dashboard and sort by lifetime value. Look at the top ten names.
- 2Count how many people have bought more than once. Repeat buyers had full information the second time; they are the closest thing to a verdict you will ever get.
- 3Check whether your highest-value customers came from your cheapest product. If they did, the cheap product is doing a job and should not be judged on its own margin.
- 4Look at views and buyers for the product being questioned. A page with plenty of views and no buyers is a signal; a page with forty views is not.
- 5Pick three recent buyers and ask them one question by message: what were you comparing this with when you bought it? Not "was it good value", which invites politeness.
- 6Write down what you learn in one sentence, then decide. If nothing in the evidence agrees with your friend, the price stays.
A worked example
Suppose your list has 63 people on it. Forty-one arrived through a free download, nineteen bought the £29 guide, and three have bought both the guide and a £120 workshop. Sorted by lifetime value, the top of your list is those three, at £149 each. Your friend's proposed price of £15 would, if it changed nothing else, have earned £285 from the nineteen instead of £551, and would have told the three nothing about whether the workshop was serious.
Now look at the other direction. If those nineteen buyers produced four refund requests and two complaints about depth, that is real evidence about price, and it came from people with receipts. These numbers are invented to show how the reading works, not a prediction about your list, but the method transfers: rank by what people did, weight by whether they paid, and ignore the panel that never opened a wallet. If your list currently lives in a spreadsheet somewhere, you can import it from any CSV and start from there.
Start free and let your customer list build itself from every purchase and free download, with lifetime value per person.
Start for freeThe mistake most people make
They set the price at a level that would survive being said out loud at a family dinner. That number is always lower than the market price, because it is optimised for social comfort rather than for the person searching at eleven at night for exactly what you made. The second version of the mistake is asking for opinions at all. Asking twelve people what they think produces twelve prices and one confused creator. Look at what your buyers did, look at the plan you are on and what it costs you to run, and then choose.
Then their opinion is worth more, but still less than a purchase. Peers price against their own costs and their own audience, both of which are invisible to you. Take the specific objection, ignore the number they suggest.
Ask about the comparison, not the number: what else were you looking at before you bought this. It is easy to answer, it produces concrete names, and it tells you where you actually sit in their mind.
Usually it means the promise is wrong. People rarely ask for money back because of the number on the button; they ask because what they received was not the thing the page led them to expect.
Give them the thing for nothing if you want to, but do not price the product around them. A private gift costs you one sale; a price set for non-buyers costs you every sale after it.
Your friend was being honest. They told you what the thing is worth to a person who does not need it, which is the one piece of pricing information you can safely put down. The people who do need it have already been telling you what they think, one payment at a time, and that conversation is sitting in your dashboard waiting to be read.
Put your buyers, their history and their lifetime value in one place, and price from evidence instead of dinner.
Open a free accountTurn your knowledge into income
Launch your Store.Fan in minutes — sell digital products, courses, and calls straight from your bio. Free to start.
